Hartley Inn Restaurant

"Warm, quaint inn that we'd visited before; this time and from a fair-sized number of selections my wife and I independently both landed on the open-face meatloaf sandwich (my wife followed with some tiramisu). Hit the spot and at a good price. The pie, cookie, and general dessert options stand out for those with a sweet tooth."

"This place is cute but there's a few things that kind of bother me. I ordered the two eggs and toast that was supposed to be 4.29. But got charged an extra dollar for the toast that was included with that meal choice. I get it's just a dollar but imagine them randomly adding a dollar to everyone's meal. And they try to upcharge without warning you. Luckily I paid close attention so I could say no. I did order homefries and knew it was an upcharge for onions and peppers but she didn't say anything and asked if I wanted to add them. I said yes, since I knew. Then she asked if I wanted bacon like it came with the meal when I knew it didn't and was a charge of 2.99. I said no. But I feel like that's how you can sucker someone into spending more than they wanted by asking so casually if they want the items like they're already included when they're not. It feels like you're being tricked. I realize it's not a lot of money but tacking on all these extras makes you spend more than what was planned. Also I barely got any potatoes, the onions and peppers weren't even cooked and my potatoes and eggs were cold. My SO was happy with his meal, I could see the stream on his. They let my food get cold to serve ours together. The eggs tasted good despite being cold. I don't think I want to go back. I'm just disappointed."

"Atmosphere is old timey old fashioned which I like. The chairs - tables could be cleaned better. They are short staffed. Don't get the mini tacos terrible. I apologize but I had the server return them. Some of the food is good The pie is good"

"quiet place where you can also hold meetings. Very family orientated, a place that seems to have a lot of history. Food by was amazing with a plethora of food options. Open street parking. There is however steps to get into the building so handicapped would not be an option. Wait staff is pleasant and attentive. Comfortable self seating with tables and booths. Very inexpensive. A deal for the price."

"I only managed to get a picture of the my pie. LoL I'll add more next time we go. Food was excellent, I had the seafood platter and my wife had the hot Turkey with gravy and mashed potatoes. Hers was excellent as was mine. They have the best coleslaw of anyone. It's ground and very creamy. So if you like this style you'll love theirs. The pie is homemade and you can taste the difference. My wife had apple and it was absolutely delicious as was my berry. Finally found a home cooking family restaurant. Locally owned and operated. Met the owner who was the chef. We will be back over and over."

"Ate lunch had the cream of chicken over biscuits with mashed potatoes. It was delicious. The waitresses were attentive and very friendly. Nice clean atmosphere, definitely a nice local place I will be visiting again. The prices were very reasonable for the amount of food given."

"Good, home cooked comfort food in a quaint historic inn filled with antiques. We always make a point to have a meal here when we're in town."